Ice Cream Pie Menu

We can create custom ice cream pies for any occasion, starting at $18.

Each pie starts with your choice of Oreo crust, graham cracker crust, or GF graham cracker crust. (GF +$2 extra)

The crust is filled with any ice cream of your choice from our menu. (Herrell’s No-Moo Vegan ice cream +$2)

Each pie is then topped with your choice of 2 toppings from our ice cream menu.

Additional toppings are available for an extra charge.

Below are some of our favorite pies. You may order any of these, or create your own!

Oreo Lovers

Oreo Crust
Oreo Ice Cream
Hot Fudge
Crushed Oreos

 

PB Cup Nightmare

Oreo Crust
PB Cup Nightmare Ice Cream
Peanut Butter Sauce
Peanut Butter Cups

 

Peanut Butter and Jelly

Graham Cracker Crust
Black Raspberry Ice Cream
Peanut Butter Sauce
Chopped Peanuts

 

Brownie Lovers Pie

Oreo Crust
Brownie Chunk Ice Cream
Broken Brownie Pieces
Hot Fudge

Grasshopper Pie

Oreo Crust
Mint Chip Ice Cream
Cake Crunchies
Hot Fudge

 

 

Topping Substitutions:
Fresh Whipped Cream
Hot Fudge
Hot Caramel
Hershey’s Syrup
Marshmallow Fluff
Peanut Butter Sauce
Peanut Butter Cups
Reese’s Pieces
M&Ms
Chocolate Chips
Oreos
Cake Crunchies
Heath Bar
Strawberries
Pineapple
Toasted Coconut Flakes
Almonds
Walnuts
Peanuts
Gummy Bears
Cotton Candy Crunch
Unicorn Bark
Nerds
Skittles
Rainbow Sprinkles
Chocolate Sprinkles

Cookie Monster

Graham Cracker Crust
Cookie Monster Ice Cream
Cookie Dough Bites
Crushed Oreos

 

Fluffernutter

Graham Cracker Crust
PB Chip Swirl Ice Cream
 Peanut Butter Sauce
Marshmallow Fluff

 

M&M Pie

Oreo Crust
Chocolate Chip Ice Cream
M&Ms
Hershey’s Chocolate Syrup

 

S’Mores¬†

Graham Cracker Crust
Vanilla Ice Cream
Marshmellow Fluff
Hot Fudge

 

Caramel Lovers

Graham Cracker Crust
Dulce de Leche Ice Cream
Caramel
Heath Bar

 

 

Main Street Creamery & Cafe